Yankees Championship! Poor argument for salary caps.

Baseball 15 Nov 2009

yankess celebrate

Congratulations to the New York Yankees for winning their 27th World Series Championship in the franchise’s storied 107 year history! Of course, with a payroll of over $208 million (over $50M more than the next highest team salary in MLB) they should have won…right?

Probably more than any of their 26 other championships, this Yankees’ victory has been like a burning match thrown into the “Salary Cap” powder keg, igniting an explosive outcry from fans who feel the balance of power and opportunity for all teams in MLB to compete has been destroyed. More than ever, fans of teams like the Pirates, Royals, Marlins and Padres yearn for a system like those that exist in the NFL and NBA where team payrolls are artificially capped to force equality in resources, and theoretically competitive balance amongst all the teams.

Unfortunately, for these self proclaimed underprivileged and forsaken fans of the baseball world, the truth of the matter is that there is no concrete evidence that salary caps significantly increase the chances for all teams to win championships. Looking at the other major professional sports leagues that have incorporated salary caps, purportedly to improve the league’s competitive balance, there appears to be only one true function that the salary caps in place have served – to provide controllable and predictable costs for team owners. Let’s take a look at some of the evidence that debunks the competitive balance myth.

Let me preface the assertions that follow by saying that I do believe teams with significantly more financial resources should have a better chance of success on the field if their management can effectively identify, develop, and direct talent. However, if it was true that the Yankees “bought” themselves a championship this season, and that money is the deciding factor in bringing pride and top bragging rights to your city and fans, then why haven’t the highest spending teams won it all every year? Why is this the first time in 9 years that the Bronx Bombers have gone the distance, despite boasting the highest payroll each of the past 9 seasons?

For that matter how come the Yankees haven’t taken home the trophy even half of the time? Heck, how come in just just looking over the past 22 years, most of the time the highest paying teams have not even made it to the World series, let alone win it? Since 1988 the teams with the highest team payroll have made it to the World Series 7 times, and won it only 5 times – that’s a less than 25% chance of winning it all while spending it all over the past 22 seasons. The fact is, 8 different organizations have won the World Series over the past 9 seasons, and there have been 19 different organizations win it all over the past 27 years. By comparison the NFL, supposedly more competitively balanced by their salary cap structure, had only 6 different winners during the past 9 seasons, and 14 over the past 27.

As for the reportedly more balanced NBA (which was heralded as the example of healthy competitive balance created through their salary cap system by baseball ownership representatives during the labor negotiations in 1994), they’ve had only 5 different teams win it all over the past 9 seasons, and only 8 different cities have celebrated in the streets since instituting their equalizing salary cap in 1984! Hmmmm…do you think the Detroit Lions or L.A. Clipper fans are feeling the parity right now in their salary capped leagues? Does the fact that last year 6 NBA teams lost over 70% of their games, or that Vegas odds makers only give 5 teams in their entire league a better than 10% chance of winning the title scream out competitive balance, parity, and more enjoyment for their fans?

Looking at it from a slightly different angle, there was a report done in 2002 calculating the disparity in salaries between MLB teams, and the corresponding disparity in wins between the teams using data spanning from 1929 – 2002. Probably to no one’s surprise the disparity in payroll between teams almost doubled during that 74 year span. However, what may be eye opening is the fact that during that period while payroll disparities were increasing, the disparity of victories between teams throughout MLB had stayed the same in the A.L. and actually decreased by 20% in the N.L.! In other words, despite the difference in salaries between the “Haves” and “Have Nots” almost doubling since 1929, the competitve balance remained the same in the A.L. and it actually improved in the N.L. Part of this phenomenon may be explained by the addition of more talent to the overall pool of players with the addition of African-American athletes in 1945, and later with the influx of foreign players from South America, Asia, Australia, Canada, etc. over the past 30 years. The point is, more than ever it is getting harder to significantly improve your chances of winning a championship simply by spending more money.

There are countless other examples, statistics, and breakdowns of how MLB has had a greater diversity of winners and losers at every end of the financial spectrum than either of the other two major sports leagues which do have salary caps in place. But the bottom line is this – it’s not how much you spend, it’s how you spend it. It’s not the players fault if certain MLB owners have been unable to produce competitive teams or reportedly make a profit during the industry’s “Golden Age”. An industry that is the only legal monopoly in the United States, which reportedly generated over $6.6 Billion in revenue just last year, and gives tens of millions of dollars through revenue sharing to it’s supposedly financially neediest clubs. Fans have a right to be mad if their team is a perennial loser because in most cases, and now more than ever, it has less to do with payroll, and a lot more to do with inept front office management, or a continued commitment to mediocrity by their team’s ownership.

Go ahead, Pirate fans, and get mad that the Yankees won, but try not to automatically take the easy route and blame it all on the Players Union for refusing to accept a hard salary cap. Poor management, misguided player evaluation, player underperformance, irresponsible use of funds, and ownership apathy are prevalent in every sports league, salary cap or not.

A tip of the cap to the Yankees players, coaches, management, and ownership who earned a championship this season, in what many still consider to be the most competitive league in all of sports.

Scan

← Adrian..should he stay, or should he go now?

414 Comments

  1. pea coat men
    November 30, 2013 at 12:00 pm

    College thinks nice post here. You must check out the wear and coats styles!


  2. portefeuille homme longchamp pas cher
    October 17, 2013 at 12:45 am

    Headline pouvez-Vous choisir us seul parmi l’effect des nombreux qui sont disponib? Quels sont ceux qui vont corp?Ter moins cher? Crush’effect des sont celfeel qui sont p mieux adaptés à votre peau et votre draw the sword? Are likely to be plupart signifiants gens trouvent qu’il s’av’e rrtre difficile prendre une décision à propos Sac Longchamps Pas Cher s. Dans cet fabric, Il sera proposer quelques pistes pots. Faire l’ordre dom ce processus plus décision beaucoup easy.


  3. herve leger size 14
    August 20, 2013 at 12:52 am

    Buying one of these dresses, via an online retailer is a good exemplar in many cases. I believe. Most of online retailers present better deals than many according to rule supplies; they have a lower price than a orally transmitted fund. May be many family will have such torment: cheap price proceeds, is very well. But the peculiarity, the service, can they have security|warrant|assurance|guarantee}? I haven’t belief. What’s more, shopping online? Is it really unhurt? I have no actual observation of shopping online, I am fear|timid|distrustful|anxious|alarmed|afraid} I run into the rogue.


  4. herve leger wrap dress
    August 20, 2013 at 12:48 am

    However, how to meet with such area, how to buy those cheap Herve Leger garments? Sometimes, it seems very firm. There are so many shops where exchange those clothes in the society, which one has cheap garments in elevated quality?


  5. herve leger size 4
    August 20, 2013 at 12:48 am

    Now, there are few tips for your deliberation. I confidence those tips can help you discover the low-priced duplicate Herve Leger garments.


  6. herve leger signature bandage dress
    August 20, 2013 at 12:42 am

    I am sure different women have different opinions, just as one thousand clan have one thousand thoughts. May be some women consider Dior is the best clothes in there organ of circulation; May be some women think Parada is the best delight in, or may be having women are faithful fans of D


  7. herve leger 90210
    August 20, 2013 at 12:39 am

    Women have a universal character that is affectionate beauty, have affection for clothes, especially amazing clothes. They have a assurance clan should hang on clothes if she want to be a fine someone. As for me, I firmly believe the clothes Herve Leger can let me become a more fine woman. Do you think so?


  8. dress as chemistry product
    August 20, 2013 at 12:38 am

    I am sure different women have different opinions, just as one thousand people have one thousand thoughts. May be some women consider Dior is the best clothing in there centre of circulation; May be some women think Parada is the best regard with affection, or may be having women are faithful fans of D


  9. herve leger white
    August 20, 2013 at 12:37 am

    In my impression, if you wish to fall upon such hoard|shop}, you will never fall upon. In fact, the clothing in orally transmitted hoard|shop} are all so heaven-kissing-priced|of great value|requiring great outlay|expensive}, the value are about 20,000 dollars, even more heaven-kissing-priced|of great value|requiring great outlay|expensive}. It can be called invented value, we can only have a sigh seeing the dresses.


  10. herve leger vintage couture
    August 20, 2013 at 12:35 am

    In deed, you need not to worry about those things. Shopping online has developed so many years, already become more and more time|complete|perfect|ripe|full-grown|mature}. Now, the safety enigma of shopping online is not the enigma. Of course, we also need very concerned because nobody can have 100% dependence to insure there are no jeopardy when you shopping online. While I want to say you need not filling with terror to shopping online.


  11. herve leger skirt shopstyle
    August 20, 2013 at 12:31 am

    Buying one of these dresses, via an online retailer is a profitable archetype in many cases. I believe. Most of online retailers offer better deals than many formal stores; they have a lower price than a traditional provision. May be many clan will have such badger: low-priced price proceeds, is very well. But the trait, the labor, can they have security|warrant|assurance|guarantee}? I harbor’t confidence. What’s more, shopping online? Is it really unhurt? I have no actual presentation of shopping online, I am affright|timid|distrustful|anxious|alarmed|afraid} I run into the impostor.


  12. herve leger max azria bandage dress
    August 20, 2013 at 12:18 am

    For the online site, they also have credit, they can not only proffer better prices in useful quality, but also render certain collect for use useful service. As a buyer, you can get the useful quality Herve Leger clothes in low-priced value and the useful service at the same time. In etc add, it is also a lot easier to estimate relatively prices online than it is to go to see a tell off of supermarkets and shops for the same final cause. You can alternative the best online site which fill up ample produce in cheapest value. You only need tick you mouse, you can find the fine clothes easily. Certainly, you need only worn out the fewest standard of value. Don’t you think it is a best of both worlds ways?


  13. royal blue square neck dress
    August 20, 2013 at 12:16 am

    Women have a universal emblem that is loving elegance, delight in clothing, especially prodigious clothing. They have a assurance clan should be pendent on clothing if she want to be a fair individual. As for me, I firmly believe the clothing Herve Leger can let me become a more fair woman. Do you think so?


  14. long evening skirts
    August 20, 2013 at 12:15 am

    For the online site, they also have trust, they can not only tender better prices in advantageous quality, but also ensure make ready advantageous service. As a patron, you can get the advantageous quality Herve Leger clothes in low-priced price and the advantageous service at the same time. In joining, it is also a lot easier to estimate relatively prices online than it is to visit a count of supermarkets and shops for the same drift. You can selection the best online site which invest ample returns in cheapest price. You only need clack you mouse, you can meet with the fine clothes easily. Certainly, you need only wearied the fewest circulating medium. Don’t you think it is a best of both worlds ways?


  15. herve leger aventura
    August 20, 2013 at 12:14 am

    Women have a not partial figure that is kind symmetry, delight in garments, especially prodigious garments. They have a belief people should depend on garments if she want to be a graceful somebody. As for me, I firmly believe the garments Herve Leger can let me become a more graceful woman. Do you think so?


  16. crinkle cotton skirts
    August 20, 2013 at 12:13 am

    In occurrence, you need not to gall about those things. Shopping online has developed so many years, already become more and more perfected by duration|complete|perfect|ripe|full-grown|mature}. Now, the security enigma of shopping online is not the enigma. Of course, we also need very solicitous because nobody can have 100% confidence to make sure or certain there are no risk when you shopping online. While I want to say you need not filling with fear to shopping online.


  17. bcbg pencil skirts
    August 20, 2013 at 12:05 am

    Now, there are few tips for your regard. I reliance those tips can help you meet with the cheap autograph copy Herve Leger clothing.


  18. ladies black skirt
    August 20, 2013 at 12:02 am

    In my notion, if you wish to fall in with such treasure|shop}, you will never fall in with. In truth, the clothes in traditive treasure|shop} are all so costly-priced|of big price|requiring big outlay|expensive}, the price are about 20,000 dollars, even more costly-priced|of big price|requiring big outlay|expensive}. It can be called fabulous price, we can only have a long breath seeing the dresses.


  19. herve leger v-neck bandage
    August 20, 2013 at 12:00 am

    Women have a general figure that is kind beauty, be fond of clothes, especially marvellous clothes. They have a reliance nation should be pendent on clothes if she want to be a beautiful somebody. As for me, I firmly believe the clothes Herve Leger can let me become a more beautiful woman. Do you think so?


  20. However, how to discover such broad way, how to buy those low-priced Herve Leger clothes? Sometimes, it seems very impenetrable. There are so many shops where sell those things in the social sympathy, which one has low-priced clothes in elevated nature?


  21. herve leger sale uk
    August 19, 2013 at 11:56 pm

    I am sure different women have different opinions, just as one thousand race have one thousand thoughts. May be some women consider Dior is the best clothing in there organ of circulation; May be some women think Parada is the best be fond of, or may be having women are constant fans of D


  22. herve leger ombre rent the runway
    August 19, 2013 at 11:55 pm

    I am sure different women have different opinions, just as one ten hundred family have one ten hundred thoughts. May be some women consider Dior is the best clothing in there organ of circulation; May be some women think Parada is the best be fond of, or may be having women are loyal fans of D


  23. herve leger miami
    August 19, 2013 at 11:54 pm

    In my idea, if you wish to find such provision|shop}, you will never find. In truth, the garments in traditional provision|shop} are all so elevated-priced|of vast cost|requiring vast outlay|expensive}, the cost are about 20,000 dollars, even more elevated-priced|of vast cost|requiring vast outlay|expensive}. It can be called unreal cost, we can only have a long breath seeing the dresses.


  24. herve leger style
    August 19, 2013 at 11:53 pm

    Now, there are few tips for your attention. I hope those tips can help you fall upon the cheap duplicate Herve Leger clothes.


  25. herve leger instant chemistry dress
    August 19, 2013 at 11:51 pm

    I am sure different women have different opinions, just as one ten hundred family have one ten hundred thoughts. May be some women consider Dior is the best clothing in there seat of life; May be some women think Parada is the best be fond of, or may be having women are devoted fans of D


  26. hire herve leger dress australia
    August 19, 2013 at 11:49 pm

    I am sure different women have different opinions, just as one thousand clan have one thousand thoughts. May be some women consider Dior is the best garments in there organ of circulation; May be some women think Parada is the best have affection for, or may be having women are faithful fans of D


  27. rolex watch box for sale
    July 5, 2013 at 6:34 pm

    If you were thinking what are these different grades of swiss Rolex Online all about and that if these renowned watches were available in different grades, be ready for a amazement. We are not talking about the absolute Rolexes but we are discussing about the swiss duplicate watches that are available online and are just referred to as swiss rolex watches. swiss watches are renowned all more than the world for the nice and beautiful timepieces, hence it is not strange to see that the swiss Rolex online watches are not the only brand of duplicate watches and there are other brands available too like the ever-popular swiss omega watches. Now let us discuss a bit about the grades of these swiss Rolex Online.


  28. buy rolex replica
    July 4, 2013 at 10:16 pm

    These of great altitude quality Rolex watches are given precedence while selecting trendy watches. Rolex watches for men are equally of the people as of Rolex watches for women as they gratify the needs of both of them. One advantageous thing about Rolex watches is that having dissimilarity in their making. While manufacturing Rolex congregation take the shut up attention of the latest trends and designs and finally come up with debarring pieces that companion up the latest trends.


  29. fake rolex watch for sale
    July 4, 2013 at 9:53 pm

    Rolex watches add propriety to the outlook|outlook} of a somebody but also give a boost to his mode of speech. As these Rolex are everyone treasure ownership, so they need peculiar|specific|proper} care and regard with affection. Today, you have a implicit entrance to make a election; you can go through the collections of Rolex watches and order them right away. There is no risk involved as the fire-brand has encrypted payment pages to confident your intelligence and private|personal} minor circumstances. Are you on the chase for a new edition of Rolex wakefulness, just breakers our website, and get one of your {election|election|option|alternative|choice} to swell your mode of speech. Whether you elect the old Datejust special edition or new Carbon crystal


  30. faux rolex watches for sale
    July 4, 2013 at 12:03 am

    Swiss language duplicate watches are noted all over their cosmos for their set up|fabricate|build} and make and you can light upon most celebrities wearing them and showing off that they are someone specifical. In the present age one can light upon many other specifical people apart from those celebrities. These are the people who are wearing Swiss language duplicate watches. Of long delayed one can light upon replicas of all noted Swiss language watches and these Swiss language duplicate watches are crafted so carefully that one just cannot make out any dissimilitude between them and the primitive ones. One has to bestow reliance to the persons who are manufacturing these watches because the trait of these Swiss language duplicate watches. It is extremely tough to distinguish between them and the primitive ones.


  31. Eat2surf
    April 13, 2010 at 7:49 pm

    From my experience … which means no real experience.. but almost 45 years on the planet.. limits tend to be set by those in charge so they can remain in charge… or set by those with money to keep their money.

    In the game of baseball you can pay for talent.. but talent isn’t the only factor in what makes a player perform.

    I don’t think you can buy a team.. only players. The team has to gel on its own. Sure you can pay for what you consider the best manager too… but the “best” is being defined by what has already been done.

    Let George dump his wallet. Sure, he’ll get a lot of talent (and a few egos) but I like to watch players that like to play for the sake of the game. I’m not saying you can’t make mint and still love the game… but until they want to work together as a team, they won’t win the Series.

    Baseball is a mental game. If you think you’re beaten because the team is wearing the pin stripes and is paying a gazillion dollars for its players… then you’ll be soundly beaten.

    I’ve yet to see a checkbook hit a ball.

    I’ve rambled.. But I can’t see how a salary cap helps the players… and the players are who deserve to make the money.


Leave A Reply